"The torrent you are trying to add is already in the list of torrents" but it's not

[OmeletteYouFinish]

Tried to load a torrent but the "the torrent you are trying to add is already in the list of torrents. Do you want to load the trackers from it?" message pops up. I've tried clicking yes and no, I've tried checking "Labels - Hidden" (I don't even have a labels - hidden section to check), I don't have a second monitor, I've tried rebooting uTorrent, I've tried rebooting my macbook. Nothing works???