Jump to content

bt.tcp_rate_control slows download speed a lot


svalentin

Recommended Posts

Hy, just reporting a problem I found out when I upgraded from 1.8.5 to 2.0:

With utorrent 1.8.5 I was easily downloading with speeds >8MB/s. When I upgraded to 2.0, I couldn't even go beyond 1MB/s on the same torrent. When I set bt.tcp_rate_control to false, my download speed blasted off from 500KB/s to 7MB/s and 5 seconds later to 10.2MB/s (100mbps cable limit).

I read somewhere that "bt.tcp_rate_control: Enabling this option tells µTorrent to use information from the uTP transport as hints for limiting TCP transfer rates."

I don't know how bt.tcp_rate_control is implemented, but it is not working properly when you don't have any caps or limits set.

I can't set a download speed limit because my speed varies depending from whom I download. From peers outside my country I can top 1MB/s, but from peers in my city 10MB/s is the limit.

Hope this helps!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did some more tests and here's what I found out:

- setting an upload limit has no effect (I wasn't uploading anything to anyone though)

- setting a 10MB/s download limit made the download speed jump to 5MB/s, rise slowly to ~6MB/s and then wiggle between said values. If at any time I remove the limit, the download speed drops slowly to ~4MB/s

I know it's hard to expect from the algorithm to work in my "special" case, but isn't this case present in everyday life for a fast connection? The connection will be limited by the network path toward the peer, and if 3 peers are in 3 different networks, this will result in 3 separate caps.

I can live very well with this option off, I am not complaining. Hope I'm not misunderstood.

I just wanted to report this behavior so you'll know about this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi again!

First of all sorry if I didn't notice a similar thread.

Second of all I was looking into the router's logs for no apparent reason and found out it was detecting a UTP DoS attack from the peers. Once I disabled DoS protection from the router, utorrent is working fine with bt.tcp_rate_control true.

It accelerates more slowly than with the option off, but that is to be expected and it does reach approximately the same maximum speed. With bt.tcp_rate_control false the speed graph looks like an exponential function (quickly saturating the connection), with it true the speed graph looks like a linear function. I say this it's working as advertised.

Sorry for the false bug report. Hope this may help other users with similar issues!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...

Hi, the same issue is occuring here.

I have a good connection speed with my ISP (fiber to home) and as they developed a torrent cache using tcp peers to speedup my files transfers, when downloading a torrent where co-exist UTP and TCP connections, these cache peers (on my local network) become "useless" in comparison with the UTP rates achieved.

When disabling the bt.tcp_rate_control feature, those cache connections ramp quickly to 100mbits each one and my downloads just finish in a blink of an eye without hurting my ISP bandwidth usage!

So, when on, this feature turns to a "share unfriendly" feature for high speeds lines.

Don't you think that it would be a win-win game if you guys consider to fix this behaviour on the future versions?

Keep sharing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...